Mathieu Shapiro Discusses Ninth Circuit Ruling on SpaceX Arbitration Claims
In a recent Law.com article titled “9th Circuit Rejects SpaceX Bid to Arbitrate Workers’ Sex Harassment Claims,” Obermayer Managing Partner and appellate attorney Mathieu Shapiro discussed the Ninth Circuit’s decision preventing SpaceX from compelling arbitration of sexual harassment and retaliation claims brought by eight former engineers. The court found that the claims fall under the protections of the Ending Forced Arbitration of Sexual Assault and Sexual Harassment Act (EFAA).
The complaint alleges that SpaceX CEO Elon Musk contributed to a hostile work environment through social media posts and comments that normalized sexual harassment. The decision could make arbitration more difficult for employers facing harassment-related claims.
Shapiro explained that while the decision makes arbitration less dependable for employers facing harassment-related claims, employers may still challenge deficient claims in court.
“If all claims premised on sexual harassment disputes are dismissed, the court says employers may seek arbitration of the remaining claims,” Shapiro stated via email. “For employers, the bottom line is that getting to arbitration may now require winning a fight in court first.”
Shapiro also noted that Judge Tung’s dissent outlines a potential argument for SpaceX to pursue if it appeals the decision.
“But having a serious argument is not the same as having a likely reversal,” Shapiro said. “SpaceX is in a far better position than if the decision had been unanimous, and now has meaningful ways to challenge the decision further, but should be clear that the odds are still stacked well against reversal.”
Read the full article here.
